The Seller Knows: Rethinking Trade Credit Ratings

I started out my career as a programmer several years ago doing software jobs around town. Some clients paid on time; some paid when they felt like it. I never wrote a credit policy, but I had one. When a good payer called, I picked up. When a slow payer called, I was suddenly very busy.
I was running a credit-rating agency of one. And my ratings were better than anything Equifax or Ansonia could have told me about those clients, because I was there. I saw who paid, who argued over every line, and who went quiet when the invoice arrived.
That idea sits at the heart of how we think about credit at Bulla.
The person closest to the trade knows the most
Economists call it “information asymmetry:” one side of a deal knows more than the other. In lending, it is usually framed as a problem. The borrower knows more than the bank, so the bank charges more, or just says, “no.”
But in trade there is another asymmetry that gets less attention. The seller who delivers to the same buyers month after month knows more about those buyers than any outside agency. They see how fast invoices get paid, whether orders are shrinking, whether the accounts payable contact starts making excuses. Research on trade credit has made this point for decades: suppliers learn about their customers' credit simply by doing business with them, and they have a type of leverage a bank does not, like holding back the next shipment.
A hard-working producer also chooses. They put their best product, their fastest delivery and their attention into the customers who pay. Credit judgment is built into everyday business. It just never gets written down.
Credit used to exist between people
Credit is older than banks, and older than coins. For centuries, debts were recorded between the two parties themselves.
In medieval England, a debt could be recorded on a tally stick: a piece of wood notched with the amount. The tally was then split lengthwise. The creditor kept one half, the debtor the other. Because wood splits differently every time, the two halves only matched each other, so neither side could change the record fraudulently. England's Exchequer used tallies until 1826, and burning the “old stock” of tally sticks, which were kept in Westminster, is what set fire to the Houses of Parliament in 1834.
At the great trade fairs of medieval Europe, merchants settled with “bills of exchange.” A bill of exchange was a written promise to pay a set amount on a set date. It only became valuable when the buyer accepted it and signed it. Accepted bills could be passed from merchant to merchant. Trust travelled with the paper because the debtor had signed it.
Then credit moved one step away
As trade stretched across continents and railways, merchants began selling to strangers. In 1841 Lewis Tappan founded the Mercantile Agency in New York to report on the creditworthiness of distant businesses. It later became Dun & Bradstreet.
Credit agencies were a smart answer to a real problem: you cannot know everyone you sell to. But they are an answer to distance, not a better source of truth. And as payments moved through banks, the record of who paid whom, and when, ended up inside the banks too. To trade at scale, you needed a bank account, and your creditworthiness was judged by people who had never done business with you.
What Bulla changes
On Bulla, the business that delivers the goods mints the claim. The person minting is usually the best-informed person in the trade.
We think of it in three parts:
- The claim is the tally stick. Creditor and debtor both see the same record, and it cannot be quietly changed by either side.
- The zero-escrow purchase order is the accepted bill. Before the goods move, the buyer signs a purchase order the seller created, with no deposit required. The buyer commits early, knows exactly what will be due and when, and has time to plan the payment. That acceptance also makes fake claims much harder, because the debtor confirmed the deal before it happened.
- The wallet replaces the bank account. You no longer need a bank to hold the history of who paid whom.
Every claim that is paid, late or disputed becomes part of a history that anyone funding the trade can check. The seller's private judgment, the thing I used to carry around in my head, becomes an immutable record.
Where distance remains
Not every trade has a seller that knows the buyer well. But someone usually does: the buyer's own bank. That is how letters of credit have worked for centuries. The bank that knows the buyer stands behind the payment, and the bank that knows the seller trusts that bank.
We think the same idea fits on-chain. A bank could run its own Bulla pool as the agent for its customers, funding claims where it knows the payer: its own clients, or those of banks it works with. Its depositors would earn yield from real trade, and its knowledge of its customers would become the underwriting. The problem was never banks themselves. It was credit judged by people who don't know the businesses and the players.
A fair objection
Insider knowledge is ultimately not enough to establish a viable credit rating system. There are two weaknesses in this system. First, it is hard to share: the producer knows who pays, but an investor cannot see inside the producer's head. That is why rating agencies exist. Second, insiders can be wrong: if they are too loyal to a big customer, or if they are too hopeful about a buyer they like, they might not exercise the most rational judgment.
And yes, someone could mint false claims.
That is why the claim alone is not enough. The record needs to be checkable, and the person minting the claim needs skin in the game. On Bulla, the payment history builds up on-chain, so it can be checked. In a Bulla pool, the originator typically holds back part of the value of each claim, or agrees to buy it back if the buyer does not pay. If you mint bad claims, the pool catches up with you, and you pay first.
Back to the people who do the business
At Bulla, we do not think credit agencies disappear or that on-chain systems take over. But we think the best credit information has always come from the people who do the business, and for most of history, that is where credit lived. The ledger simply moved into the banks.
With claims, accepted purchase orders and wallets, the record can come back to the people making the trade, and the producer that delivers good product to good customers can finally turn that knowledge into faster payment.
Mike Revy is the founder of Bulla Network, an open protocol for minting, paying and financing on-chain claims.